Review from a Senior Literary Consultant

This is Kelly Johnson, A Senior Literary Consultant at Books to Life Marketing.

We received a recommendation from our content researchers about your book:

“A Promise of Love by Christmas" 

Karen McClellan’s A Promise of Love by Christmas is a heartwarming, suspense-laced romance that delves deep into themes of forgiveness, redemption, and the enduring power of love. Set against the magical backdrop of the holiday season, McClellan crafts a compelling narrative of lost love, emotional healing, and the hope of reconciliation. The story follows Danielle, a woman still haunted by the abrupt disappearance of Garrett, the man who once held her heart. As the holiday season draws near, Danielle is forced to confront her past, even as a shadowy danger looms around her.

What begins as a typical second-chance romance quickly evolves into something richer and more layered. McClellan intertwines emotional vulnerability with mystery, as Danielle tries to make sense of why Garrett left her — and why someone now seems determined to hurt her. The suspense element elevates the stakes of the story, drawing readers into a gripping journey of discovery, both internal and external. McClellan excels at portraying the psychological complexity of someone who’s been hurt and is terrified of being hurt again.

Garrett’s character is equally well-drawn. Instead of simply being the stereotypical “ex with regrets,” Garrett’s remorse and determination to make amends come across as genuine and thoughtful. His creative plan to show Danielle his love through meaningful, symbolic gifts over the twelve days of Christmas adds a beautiful structure to the plot. Each gift is not just a romantic gesture but a testament to his growth and understanding of Danielle’s emotional needs.

The pacing of the novel is strong, balancing moments of suspense with tender interactions. McClellan’s descriptive style brings the festive setting to life — the lights, the snow, the intimate scenes — all reinforce the magical and redemptive energy of the holiday season. The contrast between the joy of Christmas and the darkness of the threats Danielle faces creates an emotional tension that keeps readers turning pages.

Another standout aspect is the novel’s underlying message: that healing takes courage, and love — real, enduring love — is built through patience, sacrifice, and honesty. Danielle’s journey is one of empowerment. She doesn’t simply wait to be rescued; instead, she wrestles with her fears and ultimately finds strength in vulnerability. The resolution is both satisfying and emotionally resonant, reminding readers that love, when nurtured with care and intention, can truly transform.

In A Promise of Love by Christmas, Karen McClellan offers more than just a holiday romance — she offers a soulful, suspenseful story that reminds us why love matters and how forgiveness can mend even the deepest wounds. This book is perfect for readers seeking both emotional depth and uplifting holiday spirit, making it a worthy addition to any winter reading list.

-Reviews by Kelly Johnson